Caroline, desperate for Gabriel's attention, decides to believe in the 11:11 myth. 'what's the worst that could happen?" was what she thought of while doing it, it probably wasn't going to happen anyways, but oh, the worst did happen. After wishing he would spend the nights in her room so she wouldn't be alone ever again, and him actually literally appearing out of no where after her wish in her room; angry, pissed off and freaked out, she decides to try and explain everything. It's hard though, when he doesn't even want to give her the benefit of the doubt or even a chance for her to prove she's not a crazy witch. She just got lucky, he shouldn't punish her for a wish that came true. Right?