Calling all INKIES who want inkie-worthy CRITIQUES. [CLOSED to new submissions]

@YuffieProductions I'd like to critique The Underlying Secret, if that's fine.

This is my short story, a one-shot. It's currently nameless, so just one-shot will have to do in the meantime. http://www.wattpad.com/5438340-one-shots Thanks.

Reply Report

@YuffieProductions Question: can we critique more than one book?

@DumbQueen Were you an inkie?!

Reply Report

Is the critique for every chapter or the entire book? And also do we post it on the book's comment section or just the writer's message box?

Reply Report

@YuffieProductions Okay, I'm done with the "required" edits on SuperHero. Still going to do another chapter, but i'm letting you know now so you can list it as finished.

Reply Report

Awesome idea :) I have been trying to find Inkies on here for a while (there aren't many on Figment from the swap:/)

My story is Marked at Birth http://www.wattpad.com/story/1233646-marked-at-birth

And I'll critique Ultimate Price if it is still available :)

Reply Report

@YuffieProductions Is this only for Inkies or is everybody welcomed?

Reply Report

@LadyAstor anyone my dear fan ;).

Reply Report

I'm done my review of @LandSharks first two chapters. Each over 1500 words!

Reply Report

@SunQueen Nice job! :D *checks you off*

@RetroGreen I'm sorry! But The Dating Deal is already taken. I'm afraid you'll need to pick something else that doesn't already have a critic assigned to them.

Reply Report

I'll like to add The Cursing or have it critiqued or something like that. :D

@Yuffie: This is so exciting! I'm so glad you started this. *goes to look through the list of projects that haven't already been taken*

Reply Report

@Yuffie: Has Olivia already been taken?

Reply Report

@SunQueen You are most welcome to critique more before Round 2 starts, but that'll have to be out of the goodness of your own heart. I want to make the number of critiques people receive through this as even as possible so everyone gets the same number of critiques and one person doesn't get like 5 one round and someone gets maybe just 1. But if you want to just critique for fun outside the thread, I can't stop you. :)

However, if you want to submit someone else's story to be reviewed and do another critique on behalf of that, I'm allowing people to do that, and then they can critique multiple books in the same round. That way, every book gets one review and every person gives out at least one review.

Ah, not sure if that made sense... Let me know if you need me to clarify.

@shadowhunter123 You're only required to read 1 chapter of their story. If you find that the chapter is so well written that you can't make a 500-word critique on it, please move onto the next chapter. Basically read as much as it takes for you to make a (at minimum) 500-word critique, and read at the very least one chapter.

Unless they ask otherwise, I would think posting on their story comments would suffice.

@1mccrawford Thank you! I'll check you off and send you a more personalized thank you in a few minutes. :)

@LettySpaghetti Have you down MaB and added your story to the list. :)

@CuriousKat *applauds* Very nice! Good job.

Reply Report

@Peony14 Sure thing! And nope, not taken. I've added you for that. :)

Reply Report

@LadyAstor If you can give at minimum 500 words of solid constructive criticism, you're more than welcome to join. :)

Reply Report

@YuffieProductions Yay! Thanks so much! :D *goes to critique*

Reply Report

@SunQueen No, I didn't have an account, although I went on the website often.

Reply Report

@YuffieProductions finished my critique. Don't know about the word count, but I think it was somewhere around 800-900 words. Stupid Wattpad limits, had to post three comments. Anyway, thought you should know :)

Reply Report

@clowen Ok, thanks! :)

@YuffieProductions I'm in! My story is Batteries Not Included: http://www.wattpad.com/3030214-batteries-not-included-watty-2012-prologue-void

I'll take any story to critique. I don't mind. :) Thanks!

Reply Report

@YuffieProductions Okay. Finished my critique.

Reply Report

@YuffieProductions I think I'll critique The Cursing if it's still available.

Reply Report

@KaterinaS Agh, tell me about it. My critique took 7 comments. >__> *stabs character limit* I'll check you off! @LadyAstor @elpajarodiferente Alrighty!

Reply Report

@YuffieProductions ah! sorry :) i totally will! ill check the list riiiight now ;D

Reply Report

i shall do Marked at Birth :D ill be right on it @YuffieProductions

Reply Report

I'm in! Story - Once Upon A Quest http://www.wattpad.com/story/674019-once-upon-a-quest

I don't mind critizing any story as long as its not pure romance, so just pair me up with a story

Reply Report

@YuffieProductions I'm done! :)

Reply Report